Asianart.com | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries |
Visitors' Forum |
Message Listing by Date: |
|
Message Index |
Back |
Post a New Message
| Search | Private Mail
| FAQ
|
Subject:Huanghuali or not
Posted By: KK Tue, Jan 15, 2008 IP: 76.229.131.12 I am interesting to purchase this Fangdeng. It is made in Hongkong during the republic period. I wonder if it is Huahuali? if not what kind of wood it is. This doesn't look like huali to me. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Judy Wed, Jan 16, 2008 I am afraid this is not Huanghuali. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: pipane Wed, Jan 16, 2008 Doesn't seems so, looks softer to me. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Wed, Jan 16, 2008 Judy, Pipane, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Wed, Jan 16, 2008 Close up pics look Huanghuali with the brown grain pattern. Without that it would look light brown hongmu. However may be not the ghost face burl type pattern that some people prefer. Design actually looks late republic with no exposed joints. Is there made in Hong Kong paper stickers on the back? Also roman numerals? serial number indented on the wood? If there is probably 1950s. Is there chinese character written in white chalk or black ink on the wood components? I saw one ming style republic piece for sell in Beijing for 7000 yuan. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Thu, Jan 17, 2008 Larry |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Thu, Jan 17, 2008 The light brown Hongmu can be hard to tell from huanghuali as they are both the rosewood family and have close grains and both are very dense and heavy. I always look for presence of brown grain lines and of cause ghost faces to tell the difference. Apparently it is very hard to tell especially when there is no more traces of pungent smell after so many years. Ingeneral the later period there wasn't much huanghuali left only old furniture that are recycled. The dark variety of hongmu can be hard to tell from Zitan. The piece I saw was a side table with the ruyi appron. I saw it 1 year ago at Beijing hotel and I ask the old man, he also sells jade and he says it was 7000 yuan, but republic. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Fri, Jan 18, 2008 Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Fri, Jan 18, 2008 Apparently they arte the sam species just from different part of the tree trunk. I think the darker Hongmu is from the heart wood and the lighter from the sap wood something like that. Anyway if I have time I take you some pics today. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Fri, Jan 18, 2008 Hai enclose some photos of different woods. 1)light brown hongmu 2)dark hongmu with light hongmu sap wood 3)huali |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Fri, Jan 18, 2008 other woods easily confuse with huali 1) walnut or hetaomu 2) zitan 3)anyone know what this wood is? |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Fri, Jan 18, 2008 1)light brown hongmu 2)dark fibrous grain hongmu 3) Zitan burl |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Tue, Jan 22, 2008 Dear Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Côme Thu, Aug 03, 2017 I'll be curious to know what you, knowledgeable people would reckon that Kang table's wood is? |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Côme Fri, Aug 04, 2017 Problem with picture size, sorry. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Soehandi Sat, Jan 19, 2008 Nice furniture. It looks more like southern elm than huanghuali/huali. The wood grain of southern elm is more regular, while huanghuali wood grain has vertical and horizontal grain and in a whole appearance really like a landscape. This vertical and horizontal grain that make huanghuali so hard. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Tue, Jan 22, 2008 Larry, Great pictures! Thank You very much. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Tue, Jan 22, 2008 Dear All, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Wed, Jan 23, 2008 Hi Randy, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Wed, Jan 23, 2008 Dear KK, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Wed, Jan 23, 2008 Dear Randy, the detergent test is a good one to tell Zitan from Hongmu.I notice that if you keep washing your Hongmu table top with deterget the dark color goes away and become almost light brown and when you apply linseed oil or furniture polish the dark color returns. Also old hongmu table tops are prone to splitting and they tend to shrink more than huali or zitan. Zitan have better depth grain pattern and almost like lion hair grain pattern and appears purplish red from a distant but when you apply bright light is only can you see the beautiful grains. regards, Larry |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Wed, Jan 23, 2008 Dear Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Hi KK and Randy, I just bought this antique display cabinet at auction for around US$350, three days ago. It is a reddy black looking Hongmu. However unfortunately the upper rack is missing. I suspect it is late 19th century. What is your opinion? By the way KK your Fangdeng looks Huanghuali after you polish it. I suspect this one was made from recycled old furniture, from the square patch on the corner- looks like a joint that was covered. That was common in the early 1900's. I think I read some where in a book about Chinese furniture publish by the British museum. Regards, Larry |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Dear Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Good catch Larry, Yes, it is probably made from recycle wood from older piece. You are right: it is common to find reclaimed wood in republic Huanghuali (probably Qing period as well). |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Fri, Jan 25, 2008 Dear KK, you are very lucky to buy this pair of stools.They do look early qing and in good condition. They are definitely a variety of rose wood and very likely Huanghuali. It is hard to find things rose wood these days, let along in pairs. Sometimes I would also buy furnitur in less desirable wood like hetaomu(walnut), zaomu (oak) or Zhajing (mulberry) if they are Ming style and in reasonable condition and not lacquered before. I suspect furniture that were not lacquered or painted were made from good quality wood and was intended to display its beautiful grains. It seems to be very much harder to find graceful and simple ming style rosewood furniture- like your stools than complicated southern qing style furniture. Ming style furniture do fetch alot more than qing style furniture at auctions.As with cleaning I usually follow what they do with European furniture which is clean with a wet cloth first if there was mess on it and when dry rub it with linseed oil. Regards, Larry |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Hi Randy and KK, with hongmu that have turn white, after cleaning with water there is no need to stain it, just rub colorless linseed oil on it and the color will return. It is a very strange phenomenon, because there was once upon a time I bought a square games table and was told it was huanghuali, because it look rosewood and was light brown in color. I rub it with linseed oil to polish it and it turned black brown in color and look completely not huaghuali. That was when I ask the opinion of another Chinese furniture expert and he told me it was definitely hongmu.Anyway I kept the table and when I clean it with water, it turns light brown and when I aply colorless linseed oil or polish and it turns black. However with the square zitan table when you clean it with water the color doesn't change. Also after more than 200 years there is hardly any shrinkage or cracks. I suspect alot of the Zitan that is in some collection is actually hongmu, because it can be hard to tell until you clean it with water. You can try this test. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Thu, Jan 24, 2008 The staining has been a tradition on Hongmu/Suen-Ji. The furniture in that noodle house was odd in color because they cleaned it with detergent. Over the years, the furniture were stripped off the color. Oil may help restore its original reddish brown a little bit, but all Suen-Ji are to be stained regularly to red or black. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Dear Randy, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Thu, Jan 24, 2008 Thank you! KK, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Fri, Jan 25, 2008 Larry |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Fri, Jan 25, 2008 Dear KK, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Fri, Jan 25, 2008 Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: wingchuntaiji Sun, Jan 27, 2008 Dear KK and Larry, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: kk Mon, Jan 28, 2008 Dear Randy, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Larry Tue, Jan 29, 2008 Yep that looks huanghuali. The bronze copper ware also looks original. Some are fitted with paktong ware but yours looks like bronze. Regards, Larry. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Dave Lee Mon, Feb 18, 2008 Sorry none of these pieces are Huanghuali |
Subject:None of these pieces are Huanghuali?
Posted By: kk Tue, Feb 19, 2008 Dave, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Kirkwood Paterson Thu, Mar 29, 2012 You do all seem to be a little more than slightly on the lost side I am sorry to have to point out. Hardly surprising considering there are few definitive & well referenced publications on the subject, and many contradictions among existing papers. It is a status quo I plan to correct, but in the interim: Huanghuali; Hongmu; & Zitan, are in all cases terms that are applied to various Asian subtropical hardwood species, some of which are extinct, and some further in the process of being re-introduced. The following is a brief synopsis of a few more widely referenced authors Linnean classifications of Chinese hardwood taxonomy, extant specie, including in most cases their varying specific gravities., I trust you will find it enlightening. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Tom Lyall Fri, Oct 28, 2016 Hi Kirkwood, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Kirkwood Paterson Fri, Oct 19, 2012 David, |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Florence Tan Wed, Sep 11, 2019 Soehandi was right Yours is not huanghuali. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Marcus Tue, Mar 15, 2016 Have a small 15.75 inches x 16.25 inches old Chinese looking stool very much like some seen here. It has Chinese writting on several on the inside bottom pieces. It's yellowish brown on top turning reddish down the sides and darkest red on the bottom. Oh yes, the writting was yellow/white with one character recognized as meaning son; like the numeral three with a horizontal line across it. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Roger Sun, Apr 01, 2012 So many awesome kick ass responses to this thread! Excellent! So I will throw in my two cents here as well. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Roger Sun, Apr 01, 2012 Here is an old "hongmu" table in un-restored form purchased a year or so ago outside Beijing. (link for closeups below) |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: LEE Mon, Apr 02, 2012 Hi Roger, what is the demand and price like for antique Hongmu furniture in HK. In Western countries like Australia, they are relatively cheap. This Hexagonal qing stand was bought for $900AUD. It was from the estate of Cathay Pacific airline pilot that bought it in Hong Kong in the 1960's. I bought this one because it had interesting fish feet. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: LEE Mon, Apr 02, 2012 more pics |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Alex999 Fri, Apr 13, 2012 Hello all |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: trevor Wed, Apr 09, 2014 Is this Fongdeng still being discussed? |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: H-Chan Sat, Jun 06, 2015 I am thinking of buying this 1950's wardrobe/TV cabinet. The seller says it is made of Huanghuail. I would appreciate it very much if someone can tell me if it is real Huanghuail. Thank you for your help. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: DAVID BARBIER Mon, Aug 27, 2018 can some one help me for this table? |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Kosta Tue, Dec 25, 2018 what is the period of this cabinet ? |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: david Thu, Feb 07, 2019 i would to sell it but i don t know how much and where |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Michael Mon, Feb 18, 2019 If you got huanghuali Funiture let me know and I would buy it . My whatapps +86 15861003268 |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Pk Jain Fri, Nov 26, 2021 hi - this is re huanghali chair. we moved back to san francsico and there is damage of back filigree carving. Do you know here we can get a piece that can be re attached? I can send pics. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: MC275 Sun, Mar 31, 2024 @Pk Jain - I have these same chairs. Do you have any insight to their history or construction? I happened to find this site trying to find any type of information about the style / date of this furniture. Thank you in advance. |
Subject:Re: Huanghuali or not
Posted By: Jay Bates Thu, Sep 12, 2024 Can anyone help me determine what type of wood this is or any other information regarding this table? |
Asianart.com | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries | |