Asianart.com | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries


Visitors' Forum

Asian Art  Forums - Detail List
Asian Art Forums

Message Listing by Date:
Message Index | Back | Post a New Message | Search | Private Mail | FAQ
Subject:Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: John A Wed, Sep 14, 2022 IP: 2601:601:516:4ef:840

Any help on and opinion on age and if mock or original is appreciated like always.







Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: Robert Thu, Sep 15, 2022

It's trying to be a Ru ware tripod censer, but only about 70 genuine Ru wares, including kiln wasters, are know to exist.

Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: John A Thu, Sep 15, 2022

Thanks for the response. Do you think it is made during Qing dynasty trying to copy Ru Ware or modern copy? Has signs of age but I am unsure if old or buried in backyard to make look old etc.. Any opinion is appreciated. Supposedly came from very good collection BUT we all know the storys etc so any help is appreciated. A few more photos if it helps.





Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: Robert Fri, Sep 16, 2022

Suggest you search the British Museum Online Collection for "Ru ware". There you will find a genuine Northern Song Ru ware tripod censer from the Percival David Foundation collection. Take note of the dimensions compared with yours. You might also send pictures to the major auction houses for an opinion. I think the chances of finding a genuine one, even a cut-down kiln waster, are very small.

Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: John A Mon, Sep 19, 2022

Thank you Bill and I agree about very small % I was thinking more Qing copy but thank you I will send to auction and see what they say... Appreciate the help like always !!

Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: John A Mon, Sep 19, 2022

After inspecting both I agree that even if shaved down the inch then it would be missing the third top ring impression by the metal top protector thing. The footrim looks pretty spot on do you think it is a modern copy faked to look old unlikely they made these so similar in different sizes ?? Thanks again for the education !

Subject:Re: Opinion on age of Porcelain Censor
Posted By: David C Mon, Sep 26, 2022

Hello John A
"Supposedly came from very good collection BUT".
That worries me. If it did then you can find it.
Respectfully
D


Asianart.com | Associations | Articles | Exhibitions | Galleries |